Are You Making These 5 Common Mistakes in Your Mental Prep?

Hey! Prefer to listen instead of read the Newsletter? I got you! The Resilient Reiner Newsletter also comes as a podcast! 🎙️ 

Here’s the hard truth I’ve learned after coaching riders on their mental game for years: most riders don’t lose because of their horse, a tricky pattern, or even their talent. They lose because of how they’re preparing their mind.

And the kicker? They think they’re preparing — but they’re actually making mistakes that sabotage them before they ever pick up the reins. The same mistakes come up over and over. Today I’m breaking down the five most common mental prep mistakes I see in riders… and how to avoid them.

Mistake #1: Thinking Saddle Time = Mental Prep

I can’t count how many times I’ve had a rider tell me, “If I just ride more, I’ll feel confident.”

But here’s what happens: they add hours, drill harder, and yes — the horse gets better. But the rider? Still spirals under pressure. Because saddle time trains your horse, not your brain.

One rider I worked with was schooling six days a week, and yet the moment she hit the arena, she froze. Why? Because she had never trained her mental game. The same nerves, doubts, and negative self-talk showed up every time.

👉 The takeaway: Confidence doesn’t magically appear after a certain number of hours. You build it by training your mind with the same consistency you train your horse.

Mistake #2: Ignoring Your Nervous System

Most riders try to “push through” nerves. They mistake grit for regulation.

Here’s the problem: your nervous system is designed for survival. Under pressure, it flips into fight, flight, or freeze. That’s why your breathing goes shallow, your hands shake, your legs clamp, and your horse feels static instead of flow.

I had a client who rode beautifully at home — fluid, confident, connected. But in the show pen, her body betrayed her. Once she learned to reset her nervous system in under a minute, she went from stiff and frantic to smooth and connected.

👉 The takeaway: Regulation isn’t weakness. It’s the foundation of consistent, calm, repeatable confidence.

Mistake #3: Mentally Rehearsing Failure

Visualization is one of the most powerful tools you have — but most riders use it against themselves.

I’ve heard riders say, “I keep seeing myself blow the stop” or “I can’t stop picturing my horse missing the lead.” And then, surprise… that’s exactly what happens.

Neuroscience shows us why: when you rehearse failure, your brain fires the same pathways as if you’re actually failing. You’re literally training yourself to expect mistakes.

One of my riders switched this habit. Instead of replaying what could go wrong, she began rehearsing the ride she wanted. Within weeks, she noticed her body automatically staying calm and flowing through the pattern.

👉 The takeaway: Don’t rehearse disaster. Wire your brain to expect success — and you’ll ride like it.

Mistake #4: Perfectionism Disguised as Preparation

Perfectionism is sneaky. It feels like standards, drive, excellence. But what I’ve seen time and again is that it kills confidence.

Why? Because perfection is impossible. Riders chasing it tense up, micromanage every stride, and disconnect from their horse. Instead of flow and feel, they ride tight and disconnected.

One client told me she was terrified of making even one mistake in the pen. That fear made her stiff — and ironically, mistakes came faster. Once she learned to release perfectionism and ride with presence, her whole demeanor shifted. She rode lighter, freer, and her scores climbed.

👉 The takeaway: Progress and presence beat perfection every single time.

Mistake #5: Thinking Mental Prep Is a One-Time Thing

This one might sting — but it’s true. A single deep breath before the gate, a quick visualization in the truck — it’s not enough.

Mental prep isn’t a bandaid. It’s a system. Sporadic practice fizzles under pressure. Consistent training makes confidence automatic.

The difference between amateurs and pros is simple: amateurs dabble in mindset tools, pros train them daily. That’s why their composure looks effortless.

👉 The takeaway: Treat your mental prep as a discipline, not a last-minute trick. That’s how you create confidence that sticks.

Here’s the Good News

These five mistakes don’t mean you’re broken. They’re just blocks — patterns your brain has practiced for years. And here’s the good news: blocks can be melted. Limiting beliefs can be rewritten. Confidence can be trained.

That’s what my upcoming live masterclass, Melt Your Riding Blocks, is all about. But it isn’t something you can buy on its own — it’s only for riders inside The Mental Gym for Equestrians.

When you join MGE, you’ll unlock the masterclass and the system that makes those breakthroughs stick. You get my proven system that rewires limiting beliefs, regulates your nervous system, and step into the rider identity you’ve always wanted.

👉 Join MGE now to secure your seat inside Melt Your Riding Blocks — and start riding with the confidence, focus, and freedom your horse has been waiting for.

Ride with confidence,

Nicole