Stop Overspin Penalties for Good

Hey! Prefer to listen instead of read the Newsletter? I got you! The Resilient Reiner Newsletter also comes as a podcast! 🎙️ 

It’s one of the flashiest, funnest maneuvers out there. The rider shakes out their arm with panache, sets their hand down and with the barest touch on their horse’s neck, their horse is spinning like a top. Mane flying out to the side, then they stop, impressively dead-on. 

Well, when things go well it’s like that. 

One of the fastest ways to take a maneuver that could have helped you and turn it into one that costs you is this:

You start the spin well.
Your horse is turning.
There’s speed.
There’s shape.
It feels like maybe this one is finally going to work for you.

And then you go a little too far.

Now instead of earning on that maneuver, you get hit with an overspin penalty. 

That’s why this one gets under riders’ skin so much.

Because usually, it doesn’t feel wildly wrong. It feels close. Close enough to be annoying. Close enough to know there was something good in there. Close enough to make you think, “Seriously? That again?”

And if this has happened to you more than once, you’ve probably started thinking one of two things:

Either you need to work your spins more.
Or you need to be way more careful.

Sometimes there absolutely is a technical piece. I’m not pretending otherwise.

But a lot of the time, that’s not actually the real problem.

Most Riders Think It’s Just a Spin Problem

This is where riders usually go straight into fix-it mode.

More drilling. More spins!
More micromanaging.
More trying to place every footfall.
More getting in there earlier so they don’t miss the stop.

Makes sense, right?

Except that’s also exactly how a lot of riders make it worse.

Because overspin penalties are not always happening because you don’t know what you’re doing.

A lot of riders are overspinning because they are trying so hard not to.

That’s the trap.

The penalty shows up in the spin, but the problem often starts in your brain.

The Real Reason Riders Overspin

A lot of overspin penalties start before the spin is even started.

You get mentally ahead in the maneuver.
You start forcing the spin to start instead of allowing it to start.
You brace.
You get tight.
You quit feeling what’s actually happening underneath you and start reacting to what you’re afraid is about to happen.

That is such a common pattern.

And honestly, it makes perfect sense. Especially if you’ve been burned by this before.

Because now you’re not just riding the spin.
You’re riding your memory of the last bad one.
You’re riding your frustration.
You’re riding your fear of giving away points again.

So instead of staying with the maneuver, you mentally sprint to the ending.

And once that happens, the rider’s timing usually gets messy.

That’s why I’ll say this plainly:

Overspin penalties are often not just a precision problem. They’re a pressure problem.

Not because you don’t care.
Usually because you care so much that you start over-controlling.

You want to get it right.
You know the penalty is costly.
You know you’ve done it before.
You know you can’t afford to throw that away again.

So instead of riding the spin you’re in, you ride from fear of the mistake.

That one shift changes everything.

How One Rider Changed Her Spins

I worked with a client who struggled with exactly this.

She kept getting caught in that brutal cycle where she wasn’t just getting hit with overspin penalties — she was also getting dinged on maneuver quality. She got so worked up she’d struggle with the maneuver itself, and get a -½ on the maneuver plus another -½ point penalty for overspinning. Each way. So instead of the spin helping her score, it was dragging it down from both directions.

And that kind of thing gets in your head fast.

After a while, you stop going into the maneuver neutral.
You go into it already worried.
Already trying to prevent the mistake.
Already tense.

But what changed for her wasn’t that she suddenly started trying harder.

It was that she changed what was happening mentally before and during the spin.

As she did the mindset work, she got less anxious in the maneuver. Less mentally ahead. Less desperate to catch the stop. She got more present, more aware, and more able to ride what was actually happening instead of what she feared was about to happen.

And over time, she went from getting those overspin penalties to steadily plus-halfing her spins without penalties.

That’s a real shift. An increase in her reining scores by two points solely from the mindset work and how it impacted a single maneuver. 

A real score improvement.
A real confidence improvement.
A real example of what can happen when you stop treating every mistake like it’s only mechanical.

The Mental Mistake Behind the Mistake

Here’s the simplest way I can say it:

A lot of riders overspin because they stop riding the step they’re in.

They’re so focused on the “spinning” part that they rush the start. 

They’re so focused on the end that they stop feeling the middle.

That’s the thing.

They’re not dumb.
They’re not lazy.
They’re not incapable.

They’re just mentally ahead of the maneuver.

And when your brain is at the finish line while your horse is still in the middle of the turn, your feel gets worse. Your body gets busier. Your timing gets less clean.

You cannot ride with precision when your nervous system is yelling at you to do something right now.

That’s why “trying harder” is not always the fix.

Sometimes the thing wrecking the maneuver is not lack of effort.

It’s anticipation.
It’s tension.
It’s overthinking.
It’s pressure.

And those things can absolutely be trained.

What To Do Instead

Before the spin, give your mind a better job.

For some riders, a cue like “stop here” works just fine. If it helps you stay organized, stay calm, and time the maneuver well, keep it.

But if that thought makes you rush, tighten, or start chasing the ending too early, it’s probably not helping.

In that case, try a cue that keeps you in the maneuver instead of lunging mentally toward the finish, like:

• wait and feel

• ride this step

• stay with the turn

Those kinds of cues help you stay present, which usually leads to better feel, better timing, and a cleaner stop.

And also — check your body.

Are you holding your breath?
Locking your shoulders?
Getting stiff in your hands?
Tightening your jaw?

Because a lot of riders think they need more control when what they actually need is a little less tension and a little more feel.

One exhale can matter.
One softening cue can matter.
One moment of actually staying present can matter.

Because when you tighten, rush, and anticipate, you do not usually get more accurate.

You usually get earlier, busier, and less effective.

This Applies Beyond Reining, Too

Now, yes, I’m talking to reiners here.

Because if you show reining, spins matter, and these penalties are expensive.

But ranch riders and other western riders know this feeling too.

If you ride patterns, precision maneuvers, or anything where timing matters, you’ve probably felt what it’s like to get so focused on not missing the moment that you stop riding what’s actually happening underneath you.

That pattern is bigger than spins.

It shows up in transitions.
In lead changes.
In circles.
In stopping.
In all the places where pressure makes you ride differently than you do at home.

That’s why this matters so much.

The overspin penalty is one example.
But the deeper issue shows up everywhere.

If You Ride Better at Home Than You Do Under Pressure, Start Here

If you’re tired of handing away points on mistakes that feel preventable…
If you know you can ride better than the version of you that shows up when the pressure hits…
If you’re done overthinking every maneuver and then being mad at yourself after…

Start with 5 Days to Confident Competitor.

It’s a 5-day, $33 training with short, practical lessons to help you stop spiraling, stay more present, and ride with more feel and confidence when it counts.

This is the first step I’d recommend for riders who know the issue is not just skill — it’s what pressure does to how you think and ride.

[Start 5 Days to Confident Competitor for $33]

Now get out there and ride with confidence!

Nicole